Every product on this page was carefully chosen. I may earn a commission if you make a purchase through a link. See my full disclosure.
Why settle for one guy when you can have your own harem of vampires, shifters, incubi, warlocks, fae and every other supernatural in the book? If you’re in the mood for all of that and more, this curated list features some of the best paranormal reverse harem books to keep you entertained for days on end.
Pack Darling by Lola Rock
At twenty-three, Lilah Darling is an anomaly as one of the oldest unawakened omegas at her stuck-up boarding school. Where most would be vying for a spot in a pack, Lilah is more than happy to slide under everyone’s radar.
Everything is going according to plan until the Wyvern Pack walks into her life, spewing ultimatums and threats. With her independence on the line, Lilah will do whatever it takes to ensure her freedom. Even if that means leaving behind her one chance at happiness.
Addictive, exciting and emotional, Pack Darling is a beautiful slow-burn MMFMMM omegaverse reverse harem romance perfect for fans of Kathryn Moon’s stunning duet Lola & the Millionaires. Expect an epic book hangover.
Broken Bonds by J. Bree
Ever since the accident that left her orphaned and penniless, Oleader Fallows has been on the run. Returning home was never in the cards for Oli. Those plans quickly disintegrate when she’s caught and dragged back to face her Bonds, the men she left behind.
Leaving Atlas, Gabe, Gryphon, North and Nox was one of the toughest calls she’s had to make. Returning may just break her. And once she breaks, no one will be safe.
Looking for an unputdownable paranormal reverse harem that will keep you up well past your bedtime? Broken Bonds is the answer to your prayers.
As one of the best slow-burn paranormal reverse harem books from 2021, I recommend adding it to your TBR list pronto. Just know that if you read this before September, you’ll be left on quite the cliffhanger.
The Price We Pay by Auryn Hadley
Surrendered to the Temple of All Gods by her parents, Nariana’s life irrecoverably changes when she touches the sacred pool, and her hands come out laced in black.
Marked by Zeal, the God of Temptation, Nari begins studying to become a future Priestess. But when it comes time to declare her Path, she leaves it in the hands of her God.
All she asks is to be forever bound to the two men who have her heart and the family she has grown to love. Of course, there is a price, and Nari must decide whether it’s worth it.
Read The Price We Pay if you’re on the hunt for one of the best fantasy, reverse harem romance books. Between the slow-building relationships and the unique storyline, you’ll be reading this steamy reverse harem till the late hours of the night (or morning).
Lola & the Millionaires by Kathryn Moon
In a world where omegas and alphas are prized, betas are seen. Before Lola Barnes met Indy and Buzz, she was a hopeful young beta with aspirations of landing herself a charming set of alphas.
Now she can barely stand to be in the same room as an alpha yet alone chase after one. All Lola wants is to get her life under control and that starts with moving out of her cousin’s place and finding a job.
But when Lola’s weekly night out goes awry, she lands herself on the radar of a high-profile pack. The question is will she ever feel safe around four alphas?
Lola & the Millionaires is a captivating omegaverse reverse harem romance overflowing with steam, love, intrigue and some beautiful m/m romances. Once you get your hands on this gem, you won’t be able to put it down.
Caged Wolf by Caroline Peckham and Susanne Valenti
No one willingly sets themselves up to be carted away to the hellhole that is Darkmore Penitentiary, home to the most cutthroat criminals in Solaria. That is unless you happen to be the badass cage fighter and powerful alpha wolf from the Oscura Pack.
Rosalie Oscura is never one to back down from a challenge. Even if that challenge means breaking out the notorious incubus who’s one screw loose after being in isolation for months on end and the sexy lion shifter she’s crushed on for the past decade.
But busting out three inmates from one of the most secure prisons in the realm is no easy feat, especially with the sinister vampire guard watching her every move and a mate who happens to be the alpha of the enemy pack.
What could go wrong?
Dark, dangerous and sexy, Caged Wolf is a captivating paranormal reverse harem romance that you do not want to miss. Filled with murderous inmates, waves of sexual tension and magical intrigue, the Darkmore Penitentiary series will take you on a wild ride.
Rise of the Witch by C. Rochelle
The day Vasilisa became Baba Yaga, she shed her human skin and transformed into the immortal witch of legend.
Entrusted with protecting the sacred territory of the grove and playing guide and patron to humans, Vasi has nothing but time on her hands.
But there is a sickness ravaging the forest that makes trees and animals decompose faster than what’s natural.
When three human men break through her protective wards and stumble upon her bathing, Vasi is struck with a curiosity of whether they’re the prophetized Riders she was promised.
But nothing is as it seems and as the forest falls prey to an unknown plague, Vasi must ascend to her full power before it’s too late.
As one of the best paranormal reverse harem books with an MMFM relationship, Rise of the Witch is an unputdownable must-read submersed with magical woods, dangerous entities, a badass heroine with a notorious reputation, and a dash of intrigue.
Gypsy Blood by Kristy Cunning
Violet hails from an ancient line of gypsies, allowing her to see ghosts and interact with all the supernatural creatures haunting the world.
When she learns of her mother’s murder, Violet follows the murderous breadcrumbs to a small town where her mom conducted business.
Soon Violet discovers that she is clearly out of her depth when she learns werewolves are real, Van Helsing monster killers get off on bloody battles, incubi aren’t just the things of legends and vampires exist outside the story of Twilight.
What’s a girl to do besides set their world on fire with help from her thirsty ghosty sidekick Anna?
Longing for a paranormal reverse harem romance with four powerful alphas and a talented, albeit ignorant, gypsy with many hidden tricks up her sleeve bra? Look no further than Gypsy Blood, one of the best reverse harem books to date. You’ll be in for a sweet treat.
Void by Raven Kennedy
Devicka is a Void, a rare supernatural that absorbs other‘s powers at the slightest contact of skin-to-skin. With this type of ability, she grew up feared, hated and despised. Her own mother grew to hate her when Devi accidentally stripped her of her power.
Sent to a non-supernatural school, she grows up amongst humans until she is called back and is asked to attend Thibault Academy, an elite supernatural academy.
The Four Paragons are the most powerful supes at the academy and they want Devi gone. Render, Hyde, Grit, and Quade grew up fearing what Devi is, so when she shows up, they plan to make her regret ever stepping foot on the grounds of Thibault.
Void earned a lot of unique points with Devi’s power. I’ve never really read a story where a character had this particular ability, so I enjoyed learning about it and seeing it in action. Also, the bullying aspect of the story did not last for long and was much lighter compared to other books in the bully-romance trope. This is also a standalone, so if you don’t have time for a full series, this is definitely a good option.
Read Void if you like the paranormal reverse harem bully romance trope.
Trying To Live With The Dead by B.L. Brunnemer
Ever since Alexis was a young girl, she has been able to interact with ghosts. In fact, every female in her family inherits that particular ability.
In the aftermath of a tragic incident, Alexis packs her stuff and moves in with her protective uncle, Rory. Accustomed to people ditching her after learning of her “freakish” unique abilities, she never expected five guys to adopt her into their friend group.
When one particular ghost starts taking her anger out on Lexie, she quickly realizes something is awry. With time not on her side, Lexie must quickly put the pieces together and figure out what’s wrong before she is lost to the void or loses her friends in the process.
As one of the best reverse harem books depicting a slow-burn, friends-to-lovers romance, Trying To Live With The Dead is perfect for anyone who has trouble suspending belief in the face of bully romances and insta-love.
The Magic of Discovery by Britt Andrews
When Saige Wilde’s frisky grandma mentions some new tenants, the last thing she expects is four hot as sin mages. They say they’re here on a business trip to scout a property in the next town over, but that couldn’t be farther from the truth.
Assassins, spies, operatives; as one of Radical’s elite teams, their boss Khol Larson entrusts them with a top-secret mission that sends them to Emerald Lakes, a small magical community, to locate a woman from Khol’s past.
But an evil entity is terrorizing Saige and it has plans of its own. The seemingly sleepy town may not be so sleepy after all.
Read The Magic of Discovery if you’re looking for paranormal reverse harem books stuffed with ominous prophecies, deadly secrets, and loads of steam. This MMFMMM romance will keep you entertained and itching to get your hands on the sequel.
A Life of Shadows by Kristen Banet
Infamous ex-assassin Sawyer Matthews left behind her life as the assassin Shadow, but when a job goes awry, her cover is blown, placing her on the International Magi Police Organization’s (IMPO) radar along with her ex’s.
When she’s caught by the IMPO, she will be forced to acknowledge her dark and twisted past and confront the monster that turned her into Shadow.
Read A Life of Shadows if you’re looking for a slow-burn paranormal reverse harem romance that has it’s very own magical system and a cutthroat ex-assassin who’s about to be thrust out of the shadows.
Shunned by Steffanie Holmes
Hazel’s entire life went up in flames when a fire took the lives of her parents and best friend. Barely getting by, she is given a second chance when she is offered a scholarship to an elite academy. Her plan is to coast by, get good grades, graduate and get the hell out of there.
Hazel does not count on Ayaz, Trey, and Quinn: the three guys who practically run the school and who also want her gone. However, what they don’t realize is that it will take more than a few insults and pranks to run Hazel out of town.
If you’re in the mood for dark paranormal reverse-harem books with bully tropes, I recommend digging into Shunned.
Don’t Rush Me by Jackie May
Nora has known about the dark and deadly underworld of supernaturals that haunt the streets of Detroit thanks to her psychic abilities. She has managed to remain invisible to the underworld until one night when she meets a powerful vampire who, ultimately, discovers her gifts. Then there’s that pesky problem where people, especially men, are drawn to Nora (to the point of obsession and violence).
Nora has a lot on her plate as she becomes more and more intertwined with the Underworld and its inhabitants. The question is whether she’ll make it out alive?
Don’t Rush Me is funny. Nora literally friend–zones her harem. It’s amazing. The title basically sums up Nora’s thoughts and feelings. She’s not ready for any kind of relationship, so don’t expect much in the romance department during the first book. If you make it through this, the sequel definitely gets more into that.
As one of the best reverse harem books about a psychic who puts her harem in the friend-zone, I recommend taking a look at Don’t Rush Me.
Four Psychos by Kristy Cunning
Keyla is an incorporeal spirit who has been watching over four guys for the past five years or so. This would be considered incredibly creepy if it weren’t for the fact that Keyla fades into nonexistence when she’s away from them for too long.
The guys in question are supernaturals and when they find out that they’ve actually had a fifth roommate this entire time…Well, to say they’re mad would be an understatement. Now, her stalking tendencies can’t be helped as she literally has to stay with them in order to exist, so the fact that they are downright mean to Keyla at times is just wrong.
Four Psychos has an interesting plot the involves a ghost and four scythe-wielding reapers (I think?) who are in desperate need of an etiquette and manners class.
Read Four Psychos if you like paranormal reverse harem bully romances.
Soothing Nightmares by M. Sinclair
Abandoned at the front steps of Institutum Sequuntur Somnia (ISS), an institute that houses some of the most dangerous monsters that have ever walked the Earth, Arabella has only ever known life among the nightmares.
Luckily, between her soothing demeanor and lack of fear around the nightmares, she fits right in with her team of bloodthirsty terrors.
But when a rescue mission attracts the wrong type of attention and places ISS under attack, it will take everything to keep her crew of nightmares safe.
Read Soothing Nightmares if you’re in the mood for a medium-burn paranormal reverse harem romance centered around a fearless heroine and her six nightmares: Saint, Razer, Blackwell, Cy, Zain, Damien and Amun.
Grounded by Serenity Ackles
From the moment Zera was taken by the Lycan, she has known nothing but pain, torture, and hopelessness. After all, being used as a pseudo battery to run an entire city is no easy feat. The lengths her captors would go to generate electricity from the elemental were nothing short of excruciating. Now all Zera wants is the sweet release of death.
But when an unexpected ally frees her from the confines of her cage, she runs. And in a stroke of luck, she stumbles across three gargoyles who offer her refuge. But will Zera learn to trust them?
Read Grounded if you’re on the hunt for a medium-burn paranormal reverse harem romance with m/m interaction, gorgeous gargoyles, killer magic, and electric love.
A Lady of Rooksgrave Manor by Kathryn Moon
On the verge of losing her job as a maid with no future prospects, Esther can’t believe her luck when the mysterious Dr. Underwood offers her a place at Rooksgrave Manor, a house where the monsters come out to play.
Soon Esther captures the affections of five tempting suitors: a man with a wicked alter ego, a charming vampire, a possessive Sphinx, an invisible thief and a golem made from marble.
But when a demonic entity sets his sights on Esther, it’ll take her entire harem to keep her safe.
If you’re in the mood for a historical paranormal reverse harem romance with loads of smut (and I mean loads), you need to get your hands on A Lady of Rooksgrave Manor.
Wicked Gods by Michelle Hercules
There are two sides: Idols and Norms. For many years, those with supernatural abilities, the Idols, have been the dominant group. However, the scales are tipping and anything can happen in the gameboard of the Gods.
Daisy is a Norm who has been dealt a bad hand in life and when she is offered the chance to attend the prestigious Gifted Academy, she takes it. Her plan to keep a low profile is ruined when she catches the eyes of the four most powerful guys at the academy: Bryce, Rufio, Morpheus, and Phoenix.
I cannot express how much I enjoyed Wicked Gods. The plotline is unique compared to other books in the reverse-harem genre which made Daisy’s story refreshing and intriguing. I honestly could not put it down. Also, if you like your heroine with a backbone, you got yourself a winner with this one. Daisy is not the type to take shit from anyone which is essential as there are more bullies than friends at the Gifted Academy.
If you love reverse harem books centered on the bully academy trope, Wicked Gods should be the next romance added to your TBR list.
Academy of Assassins by Stacey Burger
After being discovered wandering around the wild as a child, Morgan was taken under a coven’s wing and raised as an assassin.
With no memories of her childhood, Morgan throws herself into her training, becoming a worthy opponent against any monsters that escape the void.
When she receives an invite to the Academy of Assassins, everything changes, starting with the four hunters she finds herself grouped up with.
Read Academy of the Assassins if you’re in the mood for a slow-burn paranormal reverse harem romance that features a cutthroat heroine who can hold her own in a battle.
Elemental Fae Academy by Lexi C. Foss
Burning down a bar with a match is one thing, but with your mind, well, that’s a monster Claire never saw coming.
Upon learning that she is descended from fae, Claire is forced to come to terms with her heritage while attempting to control her burgeoning, and often volatile, elemental powers.
With help from her five mentors, Claire must master the elements before all is lost and the Fae Realm falls into chaos.
Read Elemental Fae Academy if you’re in the mood for a medium-burn paranormal reverse-harem romance with a tidal wave of suppressed magic.
Dragon Mistress by R.A. Steffan
When wanderlust strikes the daughter of a chieftain from the remote northern lands, Frella leaves home in search of the legendary dragons believed to be extinct. But when a stroke of bad luck befalls the 22-year-old, she finds herself relying on the three mysterious warriors who had aided her after an unfortunate run-in with some wayward bandits.
Forced to flee the city, the runaways venture to the caves located within the dense forests only hunters navigate. But nothing could have ever equipped Frella for the shock that came with coming face-to-face with one of the last five remaining dragons in existence.
Dragon Mistress is a medium-burn reverse harem fantasy romance centered around four knights in tarnished armor and a wanderer with a temper who must bond with the last five dragons if they hope to have a chance at saving the world.
Dark Horse by Kel Carpenter
Nothing will derail Fury’s future plans to retire and earn a coveted spot behind the pearly gates of Heaven. Everything is moving along perfectly until Fury is recruited for a top-secret mission that could bring about the end of the world if she fails.
Hesitant to take the job, the powers that be sweeten up the deal by making her an offer she can’t refuse. After all, how hard can it be to persuade three powerful alphas to not destroy all of humanity?
Vampires, shifters and fae, oh my! If you love paranormal reverse harem books filled with magic, mates and second chances, take a look at Dark Horse. Fury is a demon with a record-breaking reform rate. And with retirement at stake, nothing will stop Fury from completing her last job. Unless her mates have a say.
For more recommendations, take a look at this list of the best reverse harems.